The European integration of the Western Balkans continues to move at varying speeds; whilst certain countries are making progress in reforms and moving closer to the European Union, others are stagnating or facing serious political and institutional obstacles.

Although the European perspective of the Western Balkans remains one of the key political objectives of the European Union, the results of the countries in the region show that the path to membership is not uniformly dynamic. The latest European Commission enlargement package points to progress in certain states, yet also highlights long-standing issues in the implementation of reforms, the rule of law, and the functioning of democratic institutions.

Whilst Montenegro continues to advance in the accession process and Albania is making strides despite persistent challenges, Kosovo* is facing the consequences of political instability and a slowdown in reform processes. An additional obstacle is the fact that its application for EU membership has still not been given the green light by member states.

To what extent is the European integration of the region's countries today the result of genuine reform progress, and how much does it depend on political relations and bilateral issues?

What role does the European Union play in this process, and what does the current enlargement dynamic mean for Kosovo*? These were among the topics discussed for EUpravo zato by Miloš Pavković of the European Policy Centre.

What picture of the region's progress does the latest European Commission report paint?

The latest European Commission report has once again raised the question of the genuine progress of Western Balkan countries on their path towards European Union membership—specifically, whether reform processes are yielding substantive results, or whether European integration remains largely at the level of formal promises. The annual reports reveal an uneven picture across the region; while the Commission recognises significant progress in certain states, others are largely stagnating or regressing. The position of Kosovo* stands out in particular, as it faces political instability and a slowdown in reforms.

Speaking on the performance of countries in the region, our interviewee highlights that among the states leading the European integration process, Montenegro holds a prominent place, while Moldova and Ukraine are also achieving significant progress - something the European Commission has recognised by formally ranking them among the frontrunners of the accession process.

Evropska unija
Foto: HJBC/Shutterstock

According to his assessment, Albania has also made considerable progress in recent years, though it continues to face challenges in the areas of the rule of law and the functioning of democratic institutions.

"First and foremost, the leader here is Montenegro, while Moldova and Ukraine are also making giant strides forward, which the EC has recognised by formally granting them the status of frontrunners in the EU accession process. Albania is also a country that has progressed considerably over the past few years, though it faces significant challenges regarding the rule of law and the functioning of democratic institutions. The remaining states are largely stagnating or regressing. Specifically, when it comes to Kosovo*, three electoral cycles and political instability over the past 18 months have slowed down reforms under the Growth Plan and Pristina’s Reform Agenda, while its EU membership application remains shelved in the Council of the EU with no indication that it will be placed on the agenda anytime soon," Pavković told our portal.

How consistent is Brussels in applying membership criteria to the countries of the region?

One of the key issues in the European Union enlargement process is consistency in applying membership criteria, particularly in the areas of the rule of law, democratic standards, and the functioning of institutions. Although the progress of candidate countries is formally assessed based on achieved reforms and the merit-based principle, the European path of the region's states often depends on political relations with EU member states, as well as the resolution of bilateral disputes. Speaking on how evenly membership criteria are applied to all states, our interviewee assesses that the European Commission consistently applies the merit-based principle when evaluating each candidate country's progress, but stresses that the enlargement process is simultaneously both technical and political.

According to him, technical readiness alone is not sufficient for EU membership, given that diplomatic relations and resolving bilateral disputes with member states also play an important role.

These are two interconnected aspects of the enlargement process, in which the European Commission monitors and assesses the fulfilment of reform criteria, whilst the European Council - where every member state holds a right of veto - makes the final decisions on key steps in the accession process.

"In this context, technical readiness alone is not enough for a candidate country to become an EU member; rather, good diplomatic relations and the resolution of bilateral disputes with EU member states also play a crucial role. These are two sides of the same coin, and this process has always been both (geo)political and technical at the same time. The European Commission focuses on the technical aspect of the process. At the same time, the European Council, in which each member state holds a veto, gives the final green light for all major steps in the process. From candidate status, opening negotiations and clusters, to closing chapters and signing the accession treaty," Pavković explained.

Will a change of government in Serbia bring a different approach to the Belgrade-Pristina dialogue?

A change of government in Serbia raises questions regarding Belgrade’s future approach to the dialogue with Pristina, as well as the possibility of establishing a new momentum in the process of normalising relations following a years-long stalemate.

Nevertheless, a change in political leadership does not imply a change in the obligations stemming from existing agreements and the European framework. The normalisation of relations remains one of the key conditions for Serbia’s progress towards European Union membership, which raises the question of to what extent a new government will alter current policy, and how much its room for manoeuvre will be determined by commitments already undertaken.

Our interviewee assesses that a change of government in Serbia could establish a new momentum in the normalisation dialogue, which has been at a standstill for the past several years. However, he emphasises that the agreements and the obligations arising from them remain in force, and that in the coming period, the emphasis will be on their operationalisation, implementation, and concrete progress in the normalisation process.

"A change of government in Serbia has the potential to establish a new momentum in the normalisation dialogue, which has been deadlocked for the past few years. The agreements and the obligations stemming from them remain valid; the focus in the coming period will be on operationalisation, implementation, and progress in the normalisation process. If moving closer to the EU is a priority for the new government, progress in the normalisation process is a necessity. However, this will also require constructiveness on the other side and breaking the deadlock regarding the Community of Serb-Majority Municipalities," stated Miloš Pavković.

(EUpravo zato.rs)